THE depth of the class divide between government and private schools in Ballarat has been quantified with a new report showing the city’s public schools are shouldering a growing majority of underperforming students.
Commissioned by state education departments, a report on the changing role of public schools in Australia found that 62 per cent of Ballarat students who underperformed in basic reading skills were enrolled in public schools.
Report author and Melbourne University professor of education Richard Teese analysed NAPLAN testing from the Ballarat region, alongside schools in other locations including Warrnambool, Bairnsdale and Dandenong.
What do you think? Have your say below
Professor Teese said public schools in Ballarat faced the greatest challenges at the start of secondary education as their cohorts included a majority of underperforming students.
“In Ballarat, if we put all public and private schools together, what we see is that 62 per cent of the poorest readers are educated in government schools and only 38 per cent in non-government schools,” Professor Teese said.
“By contrast 74 per cent of the best readers are educated in non-government schools but only 26 per cent in government schools.”
The report, included in a submission to an independent review of school funding chaired by Sydney businessman David Gonski, also found the current system of education funding widened the gap between private and public schools.
Professor Teese said funding to non-government schools should be needs-based and that growth of private schools should be carefully regulated. He said government schools had “the hardest work to do ... and are the least well-resourced”.
“And it is causing segregation. It is causing rich to educate just with the rich and the poor with the poor.”
The report found that the proportion of students from wealthy families attending public schools had declined by more than 10 per cent in the two decades to 2006.
Ballarat High School principal Gary Palmer said all students had a right to receive a quality education. “Education shouldn’t depend upon their parents wealth,” Mr Palmer said. “Every school should be able to provide quality education for every student in the country and should be resourced to do so.”
Independent Schools Victoria chief executive Michelle Green said needs-based funding must be at the same rate for all students at independent, government or Catholic schools.
“We have proposed to the Gonski review that there should be a portable funding allowance with a base component topped up for individual special needs, which would be available to government or non-government schools. “It would treat all students equally regardless of what school they attended,” Ms Green said.
A spokesperson for School Education Minister Peter Garrett said the federal government would release the review of education funding and an initial response in coming weeks.