News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Smeaton family says no to NBN tower, and fights it going up on neighbour's property 

Smeaton family says no to NBN tower, and fights it going up on neighbour's property

10 Jan, 2012 07:47 PM
A SMEATON family who declined an NBN tower on their property due to an allegedly “unacceptable” community health risk is now fighting a planning application to erect one on a neighbour’s farm.

Bernard and Carmel Righetti said they were offered $8000 a year to host an NBN tower.

But a strong sense of social responsibility to the local community would not allow them to accept the offer, the couple said.

Mr and Mrs Righetti said a tower on land they owned in Alice Street would have been too close to residents’ houses.

But a new application on land owned by another Smeaton farmer would put a tower adjacent to land on which the Righetti’s children plan to build houses.

“We are most upset that the application is riding roughshod over our family’s potentiality,” the couple said in a letter to Hepburn Shire Council.

Mrs Righetti said Australian safety standards for wireless towers were much less stringent than those imposed overseas.

She likened the issue to early safety concerns about tobacco and asbestos, adding a family member was already fighting a battle against cancer.

Her comments come as community opposition mounts to another locally proposed communications tower at Buninyong.

Residents have voted to fight plans to erect a tower there “as long and as hard as necessary”.

A planning permit for a tower at 37 White Hills Road, Smeaton, was lodged with council in November.

Mrs Righetti questioned the timing of the application, making it difficult for people to object over the Christmas holiday period.

She said the proposed 40-metre tower adjoined land where two of their nine children plan to build houses.

“The proposed wireless tower renders our (home) sites completely unsuitable to live on because of its proximity,” she said.

The site is also approximately 500 metres from Smeaton Primary School but the school’s principal, Liz Carmody, could not be contacted for comment.

The New South Wales Department of Education does not endorse telecommunication facilities within 500 metres of a school fence.

But a spokesman for the Victorian Department of Education could not confirm a similar policy.

According to the Smeaton permit application, the landholder is Mr Ian Miller.

Mr Miller did not respond to calls from this newspaper.

A spokesperson from NBN said their wireless towers would emit a “small fraction of acceptable safety limits” for electromagnetic energy, much less than power levels required by television and radio broadcasts.

“The safety standard in Australia is based on the international safety standard recommended by the World Health Organisation,” the spokesperson said.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
These towers are being forced on rural communities. They don't want them, they don't need them. This will be another insulation debacle.


Posted by Gailwilson, 10/01/2012 8:45:08 PM, on The Ballarat Courier
Im not to sure how close these towers should be to ones home.

But any farmer who is getting into bed with the NBN and Labor Govt should be ashamed after the way they have treated rural people and farmers.

This is a second class service, no faster than the existing and much cheaper existing broadband. How about laying the optic fibre out for everyone Julia? and Cath King?

It seems some people will do anything for money, but we all know that anyway!

Posted by horses bray, 11/01/2012 6:13:13 AM, on The Ballarat Courier
They can set a few of those towers up in my back yard.
Posted by Pongy, 11/01/2012 6:47:42 AM, on The Ballarat Courier
Surely all parties involved can sit down and discuss their concerns in an open and frank discussion. We are becoming a nation of whingers and are continually butting into other people's business. The adjoining landholder may alter his stance after discussion as there may well be issues he had not thought about, or he may still go ahead. It is his land and his choice. Personally I wouldn't like a tower on my land or near me, but we live in a democracy.
Posted by Over It, 11/01/2012 6:51:51 AM, on The Ballarat Courier
These people need to go back and live in caves, terrified of every new innovation. Everything has to available and be provided at the minimum of cost by the "Government" or else we protest in the streets but at absolute guarantee of no risk or else we protest in the streets. If the neighbouring towns get the service and they don't listen to the screams then.
Posted by PM, 11/01/2012 7:41:21 AM, on The Ballarat Courier
Yep and those pesky flying machines are a problem too
Posted by hector, 11/01/2012 8:19:24 AM, on The Ballarat Courier
Its fantastic to see people who do not bow to the financial offers made to them.

If there were more people like this the world would be a better place.

There are to many who are only interested in making money even if it is to the detriment of their neighbours and the general community.

Posted by nath, 11/01/2012 8:34:45 AM, on The Ballarat Courier
For $8000 a year, come put it in my back yard! Old people need to stop being such a burden and keep quiet!
Posted by I'll take it, 11/01/2012 8:42:13 AM, on The Ballarat Courier
I Wonder if the Righetti family would rather have a stinking Saleyards and Abbatoir, put in next door to them they would be happy then. To Horsebray, don't make me laugh i guess you will be quite happy to sit back in a few years time with your Slower Internet while the rest of us are getting on with the future. It is only a Bloody tower, for goodness sakes. Some people are born to be whingers , and they Just can't help themselves to spoil it for the rest of us. Get a life people and wake up it's a new era. There are other people out there not just yourselves.
Posted by Alternative, 11/01/2012 10:49:45 AM, on The Ballarat Courier
Why is the NBN guy saying anything about the safety of these towers? They fall under the Radiocommunications Act administered by the Australian Media and Communications Authority. Any legal case should call the ACMA as the first witness.
Posted by Liz, 11/01/2012 10:55:03 AM, on The Ballarat Courier
1 | 2 | 3  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
fight: Carmel and Bernard Righetti are fighting a planning application to erect an NBN tower on a neighbour’s farm. Picture: Jeremy Bannister
fight: Carmel and Bernard Righetti are fighting a planning application to erect an NBN tower on a neighbour’s farm. Picture: Jeremy Bannister

Most popular articles


Her Majesty's NIE
 
Loreto College NIE


The Courier







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...