News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Teenage student stabbed six times, court told 

Teenage student stabbed six times, court told

01 Jul, 2009 09:53 AM
A 15-YEAR-OLD male who pleaded guilty to stabbing a teenager six times at Sebastopol College has been released on probation without recording a conviction.

A Children's Court heard the teenager, who cannot be named for legal reasons, pulled out an 8cm knife from his underpants after the victim, 14, moved his foot like he was going to trip the teenager in

the school's locker corridor on February 6.

The police prosecutor told the court the teenager stabbed the victim six times with depths varying between 5cm and 7cm to the neck, upper back and chest, forearms and hand.

He said the teenager told police he had been the victim of constant bullying, but there was no evidence provided to the court to support the claim.

The magistrate described the stabbing as a frenzied attack that left a person with six stab wounds of varying depths.

The court heard the victim underwent emergency surgery at hospital and was released two days later.

The victim suffered no internal injury but required on-going rehabilitation, the court heard.

The court heard the teenager suffered from a behavioural condition and was extremely remorseful for his actions and concerned for the victim's welfare.

The magistrate said the type of offending would normally attract a period of detention, but he placed the teenager on a 12-month probation order due to exceptional circumstances.

The magistrate said a medical report tendered to the court had been of great assistance in sentencing the teenager.

The magistrate said a probationary order would provide assistance to the teenager.

Defence counsel submitted that the teenager's parents had undertaken extreme steps to get support in place for their son.

The teenager pleaded guilty to intentionally causing serious injury.

Two charges, recklessly causing serious injury and assault with a weapon, were dropped by the prosecution.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
I don't care what his circumstances are. He stabbed someone, so he should be in detention not just on probation where he's able to do it again. Our justice system has to be the worst in the world if you are able to virtually walk free after stabbing someone.
Posted by Shocker, 1/07/2009 9:03:51 AM
It seems that time and time again, the victim is the forgotten person in this type of violent crime. Once a violent crime is committed, all attention seems to exclusively turn towards the welfare of the criminal. This crime was horrendous and to excuse it so lightly, regardless of the circumstances of the perpetrator, is to diminish the value of the life of the victim to an unacceptably low level. Judges are qualified to determine that a trial proceeds according to the law, but their ability to determine outcomes and appropriate punishment is becoming very questionable. Judges should reflect community standards, not set them. They have law degrees - that's it - and a law degree doesn't give them carte blanche to override community expectations that punishment should at the very least provide some satisfaction for victims and relatives, and a deterrent for future would-be criminals.
Posted by PC, 1/07/2009 11:34:10 AM
I agree the sentence does sound rather light on the punishment side of things, but as was mentioned in the story the student was also bullied.
Posted by -jeff-, 1/07/2009 1:30:14 PM
Without knowing the full details of this case people offer their comments and condemn the offender. It sounds to me like this is a mental health issue. We are unable to tell if bullying was involved, real or imagined. Maybe he was a victim only or an offender/victim and got back a little of what he dished out?
Posted by david, 1/07/2009 4:54:34 PM
Just because he was bullied, you go to a therapist for that, you don't just go randomly stabbing people. I am 18 and I understand this. How old are you? Seriously, I think you would feel differently if it was your own child who got hurt.
Posted by sarah, 8/07/2009 4:46:25 AM
If this was in fact a case of schoolyard bullying, these are the lengths that some kids will go to so that the bullies will just leave them alone. It's not the right way to deal with things but when emotions are involved and people are pushed to their limit, these things happen. To be perfectly honest, there is no reason to bully other people as children or adults. What is so damn hard about being civil to everyone?
Posted by Blah, 18/07/2009 11:04:16 AM
I would like to sincerely suggest that the offender's expressed regret should be encouraged by the sentencing magistrate and that, in some manner or other, the young man guilty of the stabbing should be made aware of all the impacts of the crime. That is, the impact on the principal and other victims, including any financial costs to the victim, his family, the public purse, etc, and then make arrangements for him to make reparations. These reparations need not be immediately enforceable and could be made in installments, but feeling some consequences of his actions might be helpful and even healing. If a person loses some of their self-respect and self-worth due to committing a violent act, wouldn't making restitution help the person to regain that lost self-respect?
Posted by Felix, 5/08/2009 8:27:20 PM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Students console one another after a boy, 14, was stabbed at the school. Photo by Dominic O'Brien.
Students console one another after a boy, 14, was stabbed at the school. Photo by Dominic O'Brien.

Most popular articles

Photo Sales
 
Paperboy
 
Design and Print
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...