Clergy abuse survivors are pushing for a more comprehensive redress model as the Catholic Diocese of Ballarat reveals it is confident in being in a financial position to meet all compensation claims.
The Ballarat Diocese has paid more than $4.9 million in compensation to survivors of child sexual abuse and more than $1 million in pastoral support to abuse survivors so far.
But Ballarat clergy abuse survivor Tony Wardley has said while the figure may seem big, broken down it was simply not enough when it came to redress for survivors.
He estimated using the money as compensation for the victims of disgraced paedophile priest Gerald Ridsdale alone would equate to about $30-40,000 each.
“If you divide that up by the amount of survivors you’ll see how pathetic the actual compensation has been for (the Catholic Church’s) Towards Healing,” he said.
“We want just compensation, not more money because more money doesn’t fix anything. It’s ongoing care like medical, that’s where the redress scheme has let everyone down. We need specialist help from the medical side and just can’t afford it.”
Diocesan business manager Andrew Jirik has said the diocese would continue to meet compensation claims from its assets and insurance.
“The Diocese of Ballarat has drawn these funds from its own resources, including its insurer where its policies apply, without recourse to the assets of its 51 parishes which belong to local parish communities across the diocese,” Mr Jirik said.
“The diocese has been able to meet all claims to date and is confident that it will be in a position to continue to do so.”
The statement follows a Fairfax Media investigation into the wealth of the Catholic Church, which revealed the Catholic Church in Ballarat is worth more than $176 million, owning 124 properties throughout the city.
The religious institution’s Ballarat holdings are part of a $9 billion portfolio across Victoria that makes it the biggest non-government property owner in the state.
St Patrick’s Cathedral on Lyons Street alone is estimated to be worth $4.2 million.
But Mr Wardley estimated the figure to be much higher and said the amount did matter in light of the church’s exemptions from nearly all forms of taxation.
“That’s all been taken out of society, that $176 million worth of property is depriving Ballarat residents of better roads, better footpaths, better services because they are not paying rates,” he said.
“And if you took in Sisters of Mercy and everyone else, I think that figure would be a lot higher. The fact that they’ve got that much property in Ballarat and not contributing to the upkeep of the city is disgusting.”
In evidence to the Royal Commission, the church repeatedly warned that boosting compensation payments to abuse victims could lead to cuts to social programs.
But Mr Jirik confirmed to The Courier no cuts would be made to funding of social programs in Ballarat in order to meet compensation claims.
“If meeting claims for redress in the future requires asset sales by the diocese this will be done without recourse to the parishes,” he said.
In 2015, Ballarat Bishop Paul Bird told The Courier the Ballarat Diocese would have to rely on aid from other diocese if a large amount of claims were made.
Mr Jirik said this had not yet been the case.
“The diocese has not had to make a request for assistance from other dioceses, but does not rule out the possibility,” he said.
The Ballarat Diocese continues to respond to requests for compensation for survivors of abuse who are approaching the church through previously established response protocol Towards Healing, solicitors and direct contact.
The Commonwealth redress scheme for survivors of institutional child sexual abuse, which the Ballarat Diocese has openly supported, is not yet in operation.
The Australian Government committed $33.4 million in the 2017–18 budget to establish the scheme.
“The Catholic Diocese... urges the Commonwealth and all state governments to enact the required laws which will allow government and non-government institutions to join the scheme, so that victims of abuse have access to the same redress scheme no matter in which government or non-government institution their abuse occurred,” Mr Jirik said.
The scheme will provide eligible survivors with redress in the form of a monetary payment of up to $150,000, and the opportunity to access counselling and psychological services to address impacts of their experience.
Mr Jirik said during the five years of Royal Commission hearings, changes had been made in the church to ensure children were safe and abuse survivors were being treated fairly and with respect.
He said the church had:
- Reviewed and changed many of the child protection and welfare policies and procedures in its parishes, schools and agencies
- Increased staffing and resources for child protection activities with many dioceses and religious orders now having put in place dedicated professional standards offices to respond to complaints against people within these organisations
- Put in place a new functionally independent company, Catholic Professional Standards, to develop, audit and report on the way in which church leaders adhere to child and vulnerable adult standards within their dioceses and religious orders
- Reassessed past abuse settlements which have been determined to be inadequate – this has seen survivors receive more compensation and increased support
But Ballarat abuse survivor Paul Auchettl has said the church also had a responsibility to recognise and extend its help to the families and secondary victims who have been impacted by the abuse.
“It’s not about children being safe, it’s how the church responds to troubled children and children who are enduring the suffering in their family,” he said.
“Some children have buried their grandfather or father for premature death or suicide, I believe the church has turned their back on them.
“What we want is for the church to show an understanding that trauma affects families as well as individuals and then to be able to provide services for these children… because to say they are safe now is just not enough.”
YOU CAN READ THE FULL FAIRFAX MEDIA INVESTIGATION HERE Catholic Inc: What the Church is really worth in Ballarat and Victoria