News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Building beauties and beasts 

Building beauties and beasts

17 Sep, 2009 09:20 AM
BALLARAT loves to take credit for its beautiful buildings — but what about those that don’t please the eye.

Last week, The Courier asked readers to vote for their favourite city building. That prompted many readers to make their own suggestions, and critique ours, on our website.

To balance the ledger, today we offer a list of nominees for the tag of Ballarat’s least attractive structure.

But when it comes to architecture, what distinguishes the ugly from the beautiful?

Watch a slideshow of some of Ballarat's least attractive buildings

According to Ballarat architect Wendy Jacobs, many of the least attractive buildings have been determined by their budget.

‘‘I think the best thing I ever heard was from an architect I worked with, whose most scathing thing he could say about anything was that it was accountant’s architecture,’’ Ms Jacobs said.

On the other hand, many of the most beautiful buildings in Ballarat and elsewhere blew their budgets.

‘‘Her Majesty’s Theatre never made money for the developers. Everyone loved it, but they didn’t make a quid.’’

Ms Jacobs said many of our city’s architectural treasures were also built at a time when civic pride was a bigger factor than today.

But Morton Dunn architect Alan Morton said budget was sometimes used as an excuse for bad design.

‘‘When someone says ‘I’ve only got a limited budget but I want to do it well’, there are ways of doing it,’’ Mr Morton said.

He said a crucial factor was context and how a building fitted in with its surrounds.

‘‘There are some (in Ballarat) very clearly where people haven’t thought about it. They’ve taken the building out of context,’’ he said.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
You have to consider the era some of those were built in and that pink shop may look shocking but I think that was the idea. People notice it and talk about it.
Posted by aussiedale, 17/09/2009 9:36:54 AM, on The Ballarat Courier
So true. Such a beautiful city, but so many bad design elements. Why can't the private landlords take note from the City of Ballarat and restore the old commercial buildings? For example, Art Gall, Town Hall, Mining Exchange. Imagine if all Ballarat looked like it came from the same era. An era of class and style, and not one determined by short budgets and bad taste. Ballarat Architecture mirrors the people. Some pretty some so very ugly...in more ways than one.
Posted by Ro, 17/09/2009 9:55:27 AM, on The Ballarat Courier
Bridge Mall by a country mile.
Posted by Peanuts, 17/09/2009 11:38:47 AM, on The Ballarat Courier
It's a no-brainer! The Norwich Plaza building for sure! But none of us Ballarat folk would be without it. As ugly as it is, we love it still.
Posted by narnia, 17/09/2009 4:24:02 PM, on The Ballarat Courier
Ballarat has many truly horrid buildings - the whole of the Bridge Mall, the adjoining Safeway/Coles fiasco and the Big W. What sort of message does it send to visitors to be greeted by McDonald's and ugly supermarkets sitting in a desolate carpark on the way in and an ugly Big-W on the way out? The message it gives is that this town has given up. As for the Civic Hall, there is an ugly building crying out for conversion to community use - for example a gym/pool or demolition. The people of Ballarat need to do more, show pride in themselves and their town, and demand more of the council. Sadly, a lot of what made Ballarat a great town in the past has slipped away.
Posted by Trevor, 17/09/2009 5:07:59 PM, on The Ballarat Courier
The Harvey Norman in Wendouree would have to be one of the worst, especially looking from the Gillies St side.
Posted by mick, 17/09/2009 5:18:57 PM, on The Ballarat Courier
Norwich Plaza - it's a shocker. Civic Hall - knock it down. NAB building, corner Sturt and Windermere -unimaginative, cheap and tacky. Thomas Jewellers - a lost opportunity.
Posted by Dan, 17/09/2009 7:44:10 PM, on The Ballarat Courier
I find it amazing with all the restrictions placed on renovations of private homes in the CBD of Ballarat to conform with Ballarat's heritage (and it is worth preserving), that council approved the Ballarat Police station/court complex. Next time you are in Dana St stand back and have a look. It is right out of place in a city with lovely buildings and will not stand the test of time as most court houses have done in the past.
Posted by hitower, 17/09/2009 8:57:32 PM, on The Ballarat Courier
While Ballarat has a gold rush history and architecture in that period, people should remember that time did not stand still and along came the 50s, 60s, 70s 80s and a new style of architecture. While in my opinion it is bland and cheap looking, it is a historic period in time and many of the so-called retro home furnishings etc are very much sought after today. Bridge Mall and Norwich Plaza being just two of the retro buildings of this period.
Posted by david, 18/09/2009 4:03:05 AM, on The Ballarat Courier
I think the slideshow you have compiled shows some of Ballarat's nice buildings. Your inclusion of the Base Hospital and the Commonwealth Bank buildings interests me. Is it because of the 'public outcry' at the CBA? I think these two are fine examples of modern architectural styles and although some of the others are not so attractive, they are an indication of architectural styles of the era they were built. Civic pride is still strong with me and being able to move with the times is an important character we must uphold or we run the risk of becoming dated and 'set in our ways'. The silos on the other hand, are an industrial structure and by no means 'architectural'. It is like saying a steel mill is ugly. It is implied.
Posted by Passenger, 18/09/2009 8:11:19 AM, on The Ballarat Courier
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Related Coverage
MULTIMEDIA
15 September, 2009

Most popular articles


Her Majesty's NIE
 
Loreto College NIE


The Courier







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...