It was announced on Saturday that New Year’s Eve had seen the pub’s last regular drinks, with one more special farewell party to be organised for this weekend.

Several Lalor regulars lamented the news, remembering the pub as home to a second family or the venue where they met their partner.

“Thanks to the wonderful staff and friendly patrons, I built a circle of friends that have become like family to me that has strengthened beyond the bricks and mortar,” wrote Anne Fithall-Jones on The Courier’s website.

But as well as sharing memories, there was a heated discussion between readers about the future of the building and the sort of venues that were needed in central Ballarat. The debate was sparked by co-owner Brian Taylor’s comments on Saturday that he hoped to revamp the old hotel to “jazz it up” and fit in with the new trend of Melbourne-style food and wine venues in town.

The city centre has seen a boom in classy bars and restaurants over the past few years – from Mitchell Harris Wines to The Forge and Faux Bar – and it looks set to continue with the long-awaited overhaul of The Provincial Hotel opposite the train station.

This trend has been a welcome change for Ballarat residents, and also has the potential to bring in new visitors and keep existing ones in the city for longer.

However, there is some doubt about just how many upmarket venues a regional city such as Ballarat can sustain, and whether an abundance of them will exclude some sectors of the community from the CBD.

A theme repeated over and over in people’s memories of the Peter Lalor was just how welcoming it was for those who didn’t feel comfortable in other city establishments.

“Peter Lalor provided entertainment and atmosphere suitable for all walks of life,” one reader said.  

Another said: “We need more live-entertainment venues that make anyone feel welcome. I have been to the Lalor many times and have always felt comfortable with the rest of the people in the venue.”

The recent changes to central Ballarat have made for an exciting period, injecting the CBD with a feeling of energy and potential. But it’s clear that many people hope the changes don’t come at the cost of the city’s identity.